WBR0330: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
m (refreshing WBR questions)
 
(3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{WBRQuestion
{{WBRQuestion
|QuestionAuthor={{Rim}} {{Alison}}
|QuestionAuthor= {{SSK}} {{Alison}} (Reviewed by Serge Korjian)
|ExamType=USMLE Step 1
|ExamType=USMLE Step 1
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
Line 8: Line 8:
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
|SubCategory=General Principles
|SubCategory=General Principles
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
Line 20: Line 21:
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
|MainCategory=Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
|SubCategory=General Principles
|SubCategory=General Principles
|Prompt=A 62-year-old male presents to the physician's office with depression. When asked, the patient explains that he has been unemployed for several years, has been abandoned by his family, and has been abusing whiskey. He feels completely hopeless and guilty and informs you that he cannot concentrate anymore on daily activities and is constantly feeling disconnected with no interest. Which of the following is the most important question to ask during the assessment of this patient?
|Prompt=A 52-year-old man presents to the physician's office for fatigue and feelings of guilt and hopelessness. Upon questioning, the patient explains that he has been unemployed for several years, and has been drinking whiskey in excess for the past 2 months. He cannot concentrate on daily activities, has had little appetite, and has been having difficulty falling asleep. Which of the following questions is most important to ask during the assessment of this patient?
|Explanation=Depression is considered an important risk factor for suicide. Generally, all new patients presenting to the primary care office must be screened for a history of psychiatric disorders, depression, substance abuse, and most importantly, previous suicide attempts. These factors are important risk factors and predictors for future suicide attempts (among other risk factors). It is well-conceded that asking a patient about suicidal ideation will not give them new suicidal ideas. In fact, most studies have shown that patients who have suicidal ideations will be relieved when asked about their intents and will find space for discussion with their physicians about their ideations.


Asking about suicidal ideations requires a special approach, especially that some patients with medical and psychiatric disorders might not directly admit their intent to commit suicide. As such, introducing the topic of suicide before asking the question is considered a good technique to ask whether the patient is considering suicide. For instance: "Sometimes when people are feeling down and hopeless they have ideas about hurting themselves or commit suicide" is  good approach for suicide.


Patients who show risk factors for suicide or show signs of suicide intent, such as saying their are worthless, hopeless, or feel like a burden, or say they'd rather by dead, must always be screened for suicide and about the planning of the suicide (use of gun, hanging, overdose etc.)
|Explanation=The patient in this scenario likely has major depressive disorder, which is considered a risk factor for suicide. Generally, patients who present to the primary care office with feelings of hopelessness and guilt must be screened for a history of psychiatric disorders, depression, substance abuse, and most importantly, previous suicide attempts. These are often predictors for future suicide attempts (among other psychiatric risk factors). Asking a patient about suicidal thoughts likely will not augment their suicidal mentality, but rather will provide relief by offering space for discussion about their ideations.


|EducationalObjectives=
Inquiring about suicidal ideations requires a special approach, given that some patients with medical and psychiatric disorders might not directly admit their intent to commit suicide. For example, it can be beneficial to introduce the topic, prior to directly asking whether the patient is considering suicide.
Patients with major depression must always be asked about suicidal ideations.


Reference:
Patients who demonstrate risk factors for suicide or show signs of suicidal intent, such as saying they are are worthless, hopeless, feel like a burden, or would rather by dead, should be screened for suicidal tendencies and further questioned about their planned method of suicide.
Gliatto MF, Rai AK. Evaluation and treatment of patients with suicidal ideation. Am Fam Physician. 1999;59(6):1500-1506.
|AnswerA="Do you hear any voices in your head that order you what to do?"
|AnswerA="Do you hear any voices in your head that order you what to do?"
|AnswerAExp=Asking about psychatric disorders is important, but is not the most important question in this patient.
|AnswerAExp=Asking about symptoms of specific psychiatric disorders is essential, as it can lead to further diagnosis, but is not the most important question in this patient.
|AnswerB="Have you ever considered committing suicide?"
|AnswerB="Have you ever considered committing suicide?"
|AnswerBExp=Asking about suicidal ideations and suicidal planning is the most important question in a depressed patient.
|AnswerBExp=Inquiring about suicidal ideations and suicidal plans are the most important questions to ask a depressed patient.
|AnswerC="Do you have anyone who can help you socially and financially with what you need?"
|AnswerC="Do you have anyone who can help you socially and financially with what you need?"
|AnswerCExp=Asking about financial and social support is very important for a depressed patient. Suicidal ideation, however, is much more important.
|AnswerCExp=Inquiring about financial and social support is important, but asking about suicidal ideations is more essential.
|AnswerD="How many hours of sleep do you get each day?"
|AnswerD="How many hours of sleep do you get each day?"
|AnswerDExp=Too much or too little sleep are both considered symptoms of depression and must be asked in this patient.
|AnswerDExp=Too much or too little sleep are both considered symptoms of depression, but due to the plethora of signs presented in this patient, it is more important to inquire about suicidal ideations. .
|AnswerE="Is there any reason you will not be taking the medications that will be prescribed to you?"
|AnswerE="Is there any reason you would not take the medications that will be prescribed to you?"
|AnswerEExp=Confirming adherence to medications should be assessed. However, adherence to medications is not as important as suicidal ideations.
|AnswerEExp=Confirming adherence to administered medications should be assessed, but is not as important as inquiring about suicidal ideations.
|EducationalObjectives=Patients with symptoms of major depression should be asked about suicidal ideations.
|References=Gliatto MF, Rai AK. Evaluation and treatment of patients with suicidal ideation. Am Fam Physician. 1999;59(6):1500-1506.
|RightAnswer=B
|RightAnswer=B
|WBRKeyword=suicide, suicidal ideation, depression, depressive, major, hopelessness, hopeless, worthlessness, worthless, psychiatry
|WBRKeyword=suicide, suicidal ideation, depression, depressive, major, hopelessness, hopeless, worthlessness, worthless, psychiatry, mental health
|Approved=Yes
|Approved=Yes
}}
}}

Latest revision as of 00:12, 28 October 2020

 
Author [[PageAuthor::Serge Korjian M.D. (Reviewed by Alison Leibowitz) (Reviewed by Serge Korjian)]]
Exam Type ExamType::USMLE Step 1
Main Category MainCategory::Behavioral Science/Psychiatry
Sub Category SubCategory::General Principles
Prompt [[Prompt::A 52-year-old man presents to the physician's office for fatigue and feelings of guilt and hopelessness. Upon questioning, the patient explains that he has been unemployed for several years, and has been drinking whiskey in excess for the past 2 months. He cannot concentrate on daily activities, has had little appetite, and has been having difficulty falling asleep. Which of the following questions is most important to ask during the assessment of this patient?]]
Answer A AnswerA::"Do you hear any voices in your head that order you what to do?"
Answer A Explanation AnswerAExp::Asking about symptoms of specific psychiatric disorders is essential, as it can lead to further diagnosis, but is not the most important question in this patient.
Answer B AnswerB::"Have you ever considered committing suicide?"
Answer B Explanation AnswerBExp::Inquiring about suicidal ideations and suicidal plans are the most important questions to ask a depressed patient.
Answer C AnswerC::"Do you have anyone who can help you socially and financially with what you need?"
Answer C Explanation AnswerCExp::Inquiring about financial and social support is important, but asking about suicidal ideations is more essential.
Answer D AnswerD::"How many hours of sleep do you get each day?"
Answer D Explanation AnswerDExp::Too much or too little sleep are both considered symptoms of depression, but due to the plethora of signs presented in this patient, it is more important to inquire about suicidal ideations. .
Answer E AnswerE::"Is there any reason you would not take the medications that will be prescribed to you?"
Answer E Explanation AnswerEExp::Confirming adherence to administered medications should be assessed, but is not as important as inquiring about suicidal ideations.
Right Answer RightAnswer::B
Explanation [[Explanation::The patient in this scenario likely has major depressive disorder, which is considered a risk factor for suicide. Generally, patients who present to the primary care office with feelings of hopelessness and guilt must be screened for a history of psychiatric disorders, depression, substance abuse, and most importantly, previous suicide attempts. These are often predictors for future suicide attempts (among other psychiatric risk factors). Asking a patient about suicidal thoughts likely will not augment their suicidal mentality, but rather will provide relief by offering space for discussion about their ideations.

Inquiring about suicidal ideations requires a special approach, given that some patients with medical and psychiatric disorders might not directly admit their intent to commit suicide. For example, it can be beneficial to introduce the topic, prior to directly asking whether the patient is considering suicide.

Patients who demonstrate risk factors for suicide or show signs of suicidal intent, such as saying they are are worthless, hopeless, feel like a burden, or would rather by dead, should be screened for suicidal tendencies and further questioned about their planned method of suicide.
Educational Objective: Patients with symptoms of major depression should be asked about suicidal ideations.
References: Gliatto MF, Rai AK. Evaluation and treatment of patients with suicidal ideation. Am Fam Physician. 1999;59(6):1500-1506.]]

Approved Approved::Yes
Keyword WBRKeyword::suicide, WBRKeyword::suicidal ideation, WBRKeyword::depression, WBRKeyword::depressive, WBRKeyword::major, WBRKeyword::hopelessness, WBRKeyword::hopeless, WBRKeyword::worthlessness, WBRKeyword::worthless, WBRKeyword::psychiatry, WBRKeyword::mental health
Linked Question Linked::
Order in Linked Questions LinkedOrder::