WBR1128
| Author | [[PageAuthor::Vidit Bhargava, M.B.B.S [1]]] |
|---|---|
| Exam Type | ExamType::USMLE Step 1 |
| Main Category | MainCategory::Behavioral Science/Psychiatry |
| Sub Category | SubCategory::General Principles |
| Prompt | [[Prompt::The patient has an absolute right to his privacy. It’s a physician’s duty to respect this privacy and not share it with anyone, whether it be patients family, colleagues or some random person. This is known as the principle of confidentiality. In which of the following cases is a physician legally bound to overlook this principle?]] |
| Answer A | AnswerA::Spouse of a cancer patient is extremely worried about his health and wants to know about the illness, so that she can support him emotionally. |
| Answer A Explanation | AnswerAExp::A patient has full right to confidentiality of his information. Although the spouse means well, even so it will be unethical to divulge information with seeking consent from him first. |
| Answer B | AnswerB::An employee has been absent from work for about 2 weeks and the employer calls the physician threatening him that his patient might lose the job, unless he is told about the specific nature of the job. |
| Answer B Explanation | [[AnswerBExp::A physician must not give any details about a patient without his prior consent. Even confirming that the patient is undergoing treatment or admitted to the hospital is unethical. However, if a patient has authorized the same the physician can provide desired information.]] |
| Answer C | AnswerC::A colleague asks about his 17 year old son, who tested positive for syphilis. |
| Answer C Explanation | AnswerCExp::A minor cannot make medical decisions except in cases of sexually transmitted diseases, contraception, pregnancy, drug addictions and trauma/emergency. In this situation the teenager can choose to withheld information from his parents. |
| Answer D | AnswerD::State police wants to gather a person’s medical records, who is convicted of rape. |
| Answer D Explanation | AnswerDExp::Right to confidentiality holds true even in this case. A valid warrant is needed for a physician to divulge patient information. |
| Answer E | AnswerE::A patient who recently tested positive for HIV requests you not to reveal this information to his new girlfriend. |
| Answer E Explanation | AnswerEExp::The patient needs to tell all him sexual partners about his present condition as this is a sexually transmitted condition. A doctor is legally bound to convey this information, if the patient refuses to do so. |
| Right Answer | RightAnswer::E |
| Explanation | [[Explanation::A physician is bound ethically and legally to maintain patient information confidentiality. He is not supposed to discuss this information with anyone, unless specifically requested by the patient. General principles for exceptions to Confidentiality:
* Potential physical harm to others is serious and imminent * Likelihood of harm to self is great * No alternative means exists to warn or to protect those at risk * Physicians can take steps to prevent harm In the scenarios mentioned above, the patient diagnosed with HIV needs to inform his girlfriend about his condition. If not it is physicians duty to inform her to prevent harm. |
| Approved | Approved::Yes |
| Keyword | |
| Linked Question | Linked:: |
| Order in Linked Questions | LinkedOrder:: |