WBR quality checklist: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Older editNewer edit →
VisualWikitext
Gonzalo Romero (talk | contribs)
nocaptcha
980 edits
Gonzalo Romero (talk | contribs)
nocaptcha
980 edits
Line 6: Line 6:
==WBR Quality Checklist==
==WBR Quality Checklist==
{|style="width:70%; height:100px" border="1"
{|style="width:70%; height:100px" border="1"
|style="height:100px"; style="width:25%" border="1" bgcolor="SkyBlue" align=center| '''Standard'''
|style="height:100px"; style="width:25%" border="1" bgcolor="DodgerBlue" align=center| '''Standard'''
|style="height:100px"; style="width:75%" border="1" bgcolor="NavajoWhite" align=center| '''Items'''  
|style="height:100px"; style="width:75%" border="1" bgcolor="SandyBrown" align=center| '''Items'''  
|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
|align=center| '''1. Correct Classification'''
|align=center| '''1. Correct Classification'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Board  level  
* Board  level  
* Subject/Category
* Subject/Category
Line 17: Line 17:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
 
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
|align=center| '''2. Question Stem/Prompt'''
|align=center| '''2. Question Stem/Prompt'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* '''Logical order in clinical cases:'''  age  and gender → chief  complaint (time frame) → past medical history → physical exam (vitals) → ECG → image (physical exam, biopsy, CXR, CT) → Lab results
* '''Logical order in clinical cases:'''  age  and gender → chief  complaint (time frame) → past medical history → physical exam (vitals) → ECG → image (physical exam, biopsy, CXR, CT) → Lab results
* Commonly asked question prompt (i.e. What is the most likely)? {{Main|  How to create a board review question#USMLE Step 1 Question Format}}
* Commonly asked question prompt (i.e. What is the most likely)? {{Main|  How to create a board review question#USMLE Step 1 Question Format}}
Line 27: Line 28:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
|align=center| '''3. Answer Choices'''
|align=center| '''3. Answer Choices'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Clear  distractors
* Clear  distractors
*  [[Images|Image]] for each answer choice  
*  [[Images|Image]] for each answer choice  
Line 36: Line 37:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
|align=center| '''4. Overall Explanation'''
|align=center| '''4. Overall Explanation'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Included patient’s presentation (pertinent positives and  negatives)
* Included patient’s presentation (pertinent positives and  negatives)
* Integrated clinical knowledge with tested topic
* Integrated clinical knowledge with tested topic
Line 48: Line 49:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
|align=center| '''5. Answer Choices Explanations'''
|align=center| '''5. Answer Choices Explanations'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Correct answer: summarized relevant info  
* Correct answer: summarized relevant info  
* Incorrect choice ___ explanation  
* Incorrect choice ___ explanation  
Line 61: Line 62:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
|align=center| '''6. Promoting WikiDoc Use'''
|align=center| '''6. Promoting WikiDoc Use'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Used WikiDoc info
* Used WikiDoc info
* Used relevant working [[links|hyperlinks]]
* Used relevant working [[links|hyperlinks]]
Line 69: Line 70:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
|align=center| '''7. English'''
|align=center| '''7. English'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Question Format
* Question Format
* Grammar
* Grammar
Line 82: Line 83:
|-bgcolor="LightSalmon"
|-bgcolor="LightSalmon"
|align=center| '''8. References'''
|align=center| '''8. References'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Cited  used [[References|references]]
* Cited  used [[References|references]]
* Respected [[Copyright]] sources and [[How to avoid plagiarism|'''avoided plagiarism''']]
* Respected [[Copyright]] sources and [[How to avoid plagiarism|'''avoided plagiarism''']]
Line 88: Line 89:
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
|align=center| '''9. Creativity'''
|align=center| '''9. Creativity'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Visual materials
* Visual materials
* [[Medical Mnemonics for Examinations|WikiDoc-Mnemonic]]
* [[Medical Mnemonics for Examinations|WikiDoc-Mnemonic]]
|-
|-


|-bgcolor="LightBlue"
|-bgcolor="AliceBlue"
|align=center| '''10. Include into the WBR Question List'''
|align=center| '''10. Include into the WBR Question List'''
|bgcolor="Beige"|
|bgcolor="Cornsilk"|
* Included question into list of questions [[WBR]]
* Included question into list of questions [[WBR]]
* Correct classification for board level  
* Correct classification for board level  

Revision as of 22:21, 31 January 2014

WikiDoc Board Review
The Project
The Team
Guidelines
Question List
Quality Checklist
Medical Illustrations
Question Template
High Yield!
Normal Labs
Mnemonics
Test Taking Tips
Resources

Editor-In-Chief: Will Gibson; Associate Editor(s)-in-Chief: Gonzalo A. Romero, M.D.[1];Rim Halaby, M.D. [2];Serge Korjian; Yazan Daaboul; Vendhan Ramanujam M.B.B.S [3]; Mugilan Poongkunran M.B.B.S [4]; Ayokunle Olubaniyi, M.B,B.S [5]; Mahmoud Sakr, M.D. [6];

WBR Quality Checklist

Standard Items
1. Correct Classification
  • Board level
  • Subject/Category
  • System/sub-category
  • High yield topic (frequently tested)
2. Question Stem/Prompt
  • Logical order in clinical cases: age and gender → chief complaint (time frame) → past medical history → physical exam (vitals) → ECG → image (physical exam, biopsy, CXR, CT) → Lab results
  • Commonly asked question prompt (i.e. What is the most likely)?
    Main article: How to create a board review question § USMLE Step 1 Question Format
  • Jump question
  • Image in stem (CXR/CT/MRI, biopsy, graph, microscopy)
  • Question length: short (1-2 lines), medium (3-4 lines), long (>4 lines)
3. Answer Choices
  • Clear distractors
  • Image for each answer choice
  • Use of current guidelines/algorithms
  • Answer choice placement
4. Overall Explanation
  • Included patient’s presentation (pertinent positives and negatives)
  • Integrated clinical knowledge with tested topic
  • High yield content
  • Educational objective (1 or 2 take-home sentences/phrases)
  • WikiDoc-Mnemonic: own & unique or from common source (FA 2014)
  • Working hyperlinks to relevant info
  • Medical thinking
5. Answer Choices Explanations
  • Correct answer: summarized relevant info
  • Incorrect choice ___ explanation
  • Incorrect choice ___ explanation
  • Incorrect choice ___ explanation
  • Incorrect choice ___ explanation
  • Appropriate length
  • High yield facts
  • Working hyperlinks to relevant info
6. Promoting WikiDoc Use
7. English
  • Question Format
  • Grammar
  • Case story-telling
  • Punctuation
  • Word choice
  • Correct medical abbreviations from USMLE.org (i.e. for vital signs, labs, images)
8. References
9. Creativity
10. Include into the WBR Question List
  • Included question into list of questions WBR
  • Correct classification for board level
  • Working hyperlinks to WBR0____
  • Correct classification for subject/Category
  • Correct classification for system/sub-category
  • Correct classification for High-Yield
  • Correct classification for keywords
  • Correct classification for author
See also: How to create a board review question and Category:WBRQuestion

WikiDoc Links

Retrieved from "https://www.wikidoc.org/index.php?title=WBR_quality_checklist&oldid=936846"